Table of Contents
As a model train enthusiast or hobbyist, you have likely invested a significant amount of time and resources into creating the perfect model train layout. One of the key components of a successful train layout is the control system. This is where ECoS (Electronic Control System) for model trains comes in – it is a sophisticated control system that allows for precise control of your model trains.
While ECoS is a popular choice for model train control, there are many other options available on the market. In this article, we will be discussing the top 8 alternatives to ECoS for model train control systems.
Video Tutorial:
What is ECoS?
ECoS is a digital control system that is specifically designed for model trains. It allows for precise control of trains, switches, and other accessories on your layout. ECoS offers a wide range of features, including the ability to control multiple trains simultaneously, create custom train routes, and set up automatic train control.
One of the standout features of ECoS is its ease of use. It has a user-friendly interface that can be customized to suit your needs. ECoS also offers a range of accessories and add-ons, such as handheld controllers and software updates, to enhance your experience.
Top Alternatives to ECoS
1. Z21
Z21 is a popular choice for model train control, and for good reason. It is a well-designed, easy-to-use system that offers a wide range of features. One of the standout features of Z21 is its ability to control up to 999 locomotives at once. It also offers a range of accessories and add-ons, including handheld controllers and software updates.
Pros:
– Easy to use interface
– Wide range of features
– Can control up to 999 locomotives
Cons:
– Can be expensive
– Limited compatibility with other systems
2. Digitrax
Digitrax is another popular option for model train control. It is known for its reliable performance and wide range of features. Digitrax offers a range of components, including handheld controllers, power supplies, and decoders.
Pros:
– Reliable performance
– Wide range of features
– Compatible with a range of components
Cons:
– Can be complicated to set up
– May require additional components for full functionality
3. Roco z21
Roco z21 is a sophisticated model train control system that offers a wide range of features. It has a user-friendly interface that can be customized to suit your needs. Roco z21 also offers a range of accessories and add-ons, including handheld controllers and software updates.
Pros:
– User-friendly interface
– Wide range of features
– Compatible with a range of accessories
Cons:
– Limited compatibility with other systems
– Can be expensive
4. NCE PowerCab
NCE PowerCab is a compact, easy-to-use model train control system. It offers a wide range of features, including the ability to control multiple trains simultaneously and create custom train routes. NCE PowerCab also offers a range of accessories and add-ons, including handheld controllers and sound decoders.
Pros:
– Compact and easy to use
– Wide range of features
– Compatible with a range of accessories
Cons:
– Limited compatibility with other systems
– May require additional components for full functionality
5. Lenz Digital Plus
Lenz Digital Plus is a sophisticated model train control system that offers a wide range of features. It has a user-friendly interface that can be customized to suit your needs. Lenz Digital Plus also offers a range of accessories and add-ons, including handheld controllers and software updates.
Pros:
– User-friendly interface
– Wide range of features
– Compatible with a range of accessories
Cons:
– Limited compatibility with other systems
– Can be expensive
6. Bachmann E-Z Command
Bachmann E-Z Command is a popular choice for model train control. It is a reliable system that offers a range of features. Bachmann E-Z Command also offers a range of accessories and add-ons, including handheld controllers and sound decoders.
Pros:
– Reliable performance
– Wide range of features
– Compatible with a range of accessories
Cons:
– Limited compatibility with other systems
– May require additional components for full functionality
7. TrainControl
TrainControl is a sophisticated model train control system that offers a wide range of features. It has a user-friendly interface that can be customized to suit your needs. TrainControl also offers a range of accessories and add-ons, including handheld controllers and software updates.
Pros:
– User-friendly interface
– Wide range of features
– Compatible with a range of accessories
Cons:
– Limited compatibility with other systems
– Can be expensive
8. MRC Prodigy
MRC Prodigy is a reliable model train control system that offers a wide range of features. It is easy to use and compatible with a range of accessories. MRC Prodigy also offers a range of add-ons, including handheld controllers and computer interfaces.
Pros:
– Reliable performance
– Wide range of features
– Compatible with a range of accessories
Cons:
– Limited compatibility with other systems
– May require additional components for full functionality
Pros & Cons of Each Software
Z21:
Pros:
– Easy to use interface
– Wide range of features
– Can control up to 999 locomotives
Cons:
– Can be expensive
– Limited compatibility with other systems
Digitrax:
Pros:
– Reliable performance
– Wide range of features
– Compatible with a range of components
Cons:
– Can be complicated to set up
– May require additional components for full functionality
Roco z21:
Pros:
– User-friendly interface
– Wide range of features
– Compatible with a range of accessories
Cons:
– Limited compatibility with other systems
– Can be expensive
NCE PowerCab:
Pros:
– Compact and easy to use
– Wide range of features
– Compatible with a range of accessories
Cons:
– Limited compatibility with other systems
– May require additional components for full functionality
Lenz Digital Plus:
Pros:
– User-friendly interface
– Wide range of features
– Compatible with a range of accessories
Cons:
– Limited compatibility with other systems
– Can be expensive
Bachmann E-Z Command:
Pros:
– Reliable performance
– Wide range of features
– Compatible with a range of accessories
Cons:
– Limited compatibility with other systems
– May require additional components for full functionality
TrainControl:
Pros:
– User-friendly interface
– Wide range of features
– Compatible with a range of accessories
Cons:
– Limited compatibility with other systems
– Can be expensive
MRC Prodigy:
Pros:
– Reliable performance
– Wide range of features
– Compatible with a range of accessories
Cons:
– Limited compatibility with other systems
– May require additional components for full functionality
Comprehensive Comparison of Each Software
| Software | Free Trial | Price | Ease-of-Use | Value for Money |
| :—: | :—: | :—: | :—: | :—: |
| ECoS | Yes | $580+ | Easy | Average |
| Z21 | Yes | $400+ | Easy | Good |
| Digitrax | No | $250+ | Complicated | Good |
| Roco z21 | No | $480+ | Easy | Average |
| NCE PowerCab | No | $200+ | Easy | Good |
| Lenz Digital Plus | No | $500+ | Easy | Average |
| Bachmann E-Z Command | No | $200+ | Easy | Good |
| TrainControl | No | $350+ | Easy | Average |
| MRC Prodigy | No | $200+ | Easy | Good |
Our Thoughts on ECoS and Its Alternatives
ECoS is undoubtedly a powerful and reliable model train control system. However, its price point may be a bit steep for some hobbyists. The alternatives we have listed in this article offer similar functionality in varying price ranges. Each system has its own strengths and weaknesses, so it’s important to evaluate which one is the best fit for your specific needs.
If you’re a beginner model train hobbyist, we recommend starting with a more affordable option such as NCE PowerCab or Bachmann E-Z Command. These systems offer a range of features and are easy to use. If you’re an advanced hobbyist looking for more sophisticated control, we recommend exploring options such as Digitrax or Z21.
FAQs:
Q: Can I use ECoS with other model train brands?
A: Yes, ECoS is compatible with a range of model train brands.
Q: Is Z21 compatible with other model train brands?
A: Yes, Z21 is compatible with a range of model train brands.
Q: Is it difficult to set up Digitrax?
A: Yes, setting up Digitrax can be complicated. However, there are plenty of resources available online to help with the process.
Q: Can I control multiple locomotives with NCE PowerCab?
A: Yes, NCE PowerCab allows for the simultaneous control of multiple locomotives.
Q: Does Bachmann E-Z Command offer sound decoders?
A: Yes, Bachmann E-Z Command offers a range of sound decoders.
In Conclusion
Choosing the right model train control system is essential for creating the perfect train layout. Whether you’re a beginner hobbyist or an advanced enthusiast, there are plenty of options available on the market. We hope this article has provided you with valuable insights into the top 8 alternatives to ECoS for model train control systems. Remember to evaluate your specific needs and budget before making a decision.